That’s not been my experience Tom. Maybe the congregation I serve is anomaly. We are multi generational, has some serious ups and a few downs. Also a deliberate plan of helping lambs follow Good Shepherd.
Actually, I'm going to be bold here. I don't know, I'd offer that your congregation might be an anomaly when it comes to the LC-MS and American Christianity.
Here's why I posit that:
It’s located in the heart of Republican and prosperous Orange County. Certainly there are seedier sides there, but Rick Warren's Saddleback Church (located where my father-in-law once served in Lake Forest) grew in large part because of the huge demographic shift to there in the 90s. Whereas many parts of the country are declining rapidly, development continues at an amazing pace there because it's a beautiful place to live. Thus, those most likely to move there are those with the means and opportunities to do so. One of the things we always do for fun when we visit family out there is walk through all of the new developments. A little over a year ago we went to Tustin and Laguna Niguel and walked through new builds. It is simply amazing that there are always new builds, and that they sell so quickly.
Secondly, in many ways, Lutheranism in the OC is very much Midwestern in culture but in a distinct way that connects with above. What I mean is Lutheranism in OC California is more likely to be appealing to a salt of the earth Midwesterner than, say, Lutheranism here in New York. The OC is surburban sprawl par excellence with all of the familiar box stores and chains that you can find anywhere, but with really great weather and landscaping. Plus, it’s less parochial and more free form, which is going to be more attractive to the kind of person who moves there anyways. My father-in-law, a native Los Angelean, always jokes that the Holy Spirit tricked him into accepting the call there. He says this because he would learn quickly that the church he was called to was full of Midwestern transplants rather than native Californians like himself. Out there, it seems like everyone is from somewhere else.
Most importantly, though, there’s just a lot of wealth there. Just look at Orange Lutheran and what they are able to do or even Crean. To be able to start a strong Lutheran High School like that in the last twenty years is simply amazing. The brochures for that place are stunning. And while we love to invoke the name of God for such projects, let’s be real, money is a huge part. To have the capital to buy land in such a market and then build and establish a solid school. Yo! Now, I don’t intend to take away from the hard work of those involved because they should be commended, but the means were there to do so. And such means aren’t available in lots of other corners of American Lutheranism.
Please know, I don’t intend this as criticism, it’s great what you are able to do out there. This is just my take as someone who married into a family of California Lutherans and has become very familiar with the area in the last decade. I grew up in the rapidly declining Atlantic District so talk about a contrast.
Peace,
Scott+