My home congregation has been doing the Great Vigil of Easter for over 40 years, so I grew up with it. I did it for 12 years in my first parish, and will be conducting my 8th in this place on Holy Saturday. We do the whole shooting match (although we now only use 7 readings instead of 12). As for the reading for Daniel 3, I always reserve that one for myself! Crack up every year reading that puppy! For me, it just wouldn't be the Vigil without it. I especially like listening to my acolytes "go bump in the night" as they decorate the entire sanctuary for Easter during the singing of the Litany of the Saints. (They also strip the altar on Maundy Thursday while I read Psalm 22.) We practice for three hours on Saturday afternoon for the Vigil, going from bare altar to Easter splendor several times. The new acolytes usually say, "Hey, this is easy." Then one of the older acolytes will inform them that they will actually be doing this in the dark. I love the look on their faces when so informed! We average 30-60 here, depending on if their is a baptism or REmembrance of Baptism.
By the way, have any of you incorporated the Roman blessing of the baptismal water during your Vigil, chanted like the Exultet? (Again, I grew up with it in my home parish.)