1
Your Turn / Succession, Calls, and Vetting of Would-be Pastors
« on: June 14, 2022, 10:53:01 AM »
Rick Warren is a name well known inside and outside of Evangelical circles. Like many 'successful' mega-church leaders he is also an author with numerous titles to his credit. He has been popular with many church leaders, including those within the LCMS.
It is interesting, however, to see how they deal with the position of a pastor, and the implications for what we are doing even in our own places, large or small. First, they don't see the placement of a new pastor as driven by a call. It is succession. Rick Warren, like an English monarch, is able to largely determine who follows him and takes over the family business. Secondly, the scrutiny of would-be successors is greatly heightened in our era of scandalous revelations of past religious leaders (e.g. Bill Hybels, Mark Driscoll), something that could be kept largely 'in house' in past times. I found it interesting that the church employed a professional outside search group to do a background check and then a follow-up review after allegations surfaced from a former staff member. "The search company was provided video footage, emails, text records and interviews that Echo gathered in its own review of Wood’s actions. Echo had conducted its own interviews, as well..."
I wonder if this will be a sign of the future even for those of us in much different ecclesial backgrounds. When I applied for a position as a law enforcement chaplain I was told that they would do a 'deep dive' into my social media. Right now I'm not aware that our districts provide this extensive of a background search, although in some states/districts such as in Minnesota, I believe you do have to pass a sexual abuse background check with the government.
Regarding succession vs. call: I don't think it is healthy to see a church as an organization branded by one man, which then has to make sure the one following is vetted as to qualifications to maintain the organization's unique identity. I think it is helpful to know if a would-be senior pastor, for example, has had prior experience with larger churches. But a congregation should be driven by scriptural guidelines and the mission given it by Christ, and understand its mission apart from the personality of the pastor. We do not establish little kingdoms in our own honor, but we plant churches to baptize and catechize. I hope that the Rick Warren 'method' is not widely prevalent in Lutheran circles, but would not be surprised if it is, given his popularity among some Lutheran clergy.
It is clear that we are all under a much more powerful microscope of inspection. We live much more 'public' lives because of the internet and social media. One good thing is that it is getting harder for those with dark pasts of abuse to effectively hide and keep operating under the radar as they might have in the past.
Saddleback Church backs Rick Warren successor despite allegations
Questions have been raised about the leadership style of Andy Wood, pastor of Echo Church in San Francisco, days after he was announced as Warren's successor.
https://religionnews.com/2022/06/12/saddleback-backs-rick-warren-successor-despite-allegations-andy-wood-echo-church/?fbclid=IwAR0cI2RB7w-UllQhs8sF_2K3Bz42TeTL8yzV952D1N5oCEnVn8mv892tuzA
It is interesting, however, to see how they deal with the position of a pastor, and the implications for what we are doing even in our own places, large or small. First, they don't see the placement of a new pastor as driven by a call. It is succession. Rick Warren, like an English monarch, is able to largely determine who follows him and takes over the family business. Secondly, the scrutiny of would-be successors is greatly heightened in our era of scandalous revelations of past religious leaders (e.g. Bill Hybels, Mark Driscoll), something that could be kept largely 'in house' in past times. I found it interesting that the church employed a professional outside search group to do a background check and then a follow-up review after allegations surfaced from a former staff member. "The search company was provided video footage, emails, text records and interviews that Echo gathered in its own review of Wood’s actions. Echo had conducted its own interviews, as well..."
I wonder if this will be a sign of the future even for those of us in much different ecclesial backgrounds. When I applied for a position as a law enforcement chaplain I was told that they would do a 'deep dive' into my social media. Right now I'm not aware that our districts provide this extensive of a background search, although in some states/districts such as in Minnesota, I believe you do have to pass a sexual abuse background check with the government.
Regarding succession vs. call: I don't think it is healthy to see a church as an organization branded by one man, which then has to make sure the one following is vetted as to qualifications to maintain the organization's unique identity. I think it is helpful to know if a would-be senior pastor, for example, has had prior experience with larger churches. But a congregation should be driven by scriptural guidelines and the mission given it by Christ, and understand its mission apart from the personality of the pastor. We do not establish little kingdoms in our own honor, but we plant churches to baptize and catechize. I hope that the Rick Warren 'method' is not widely prevalent in Lutheran circles, but would not be surprised if it is, given his popularity among some Lutheran clergy.
It is clear that we are all under a much more powerful microscope of inspection. We live much more 'public' lives because of the internet and social media. One good thing is that it is getting harder for those with dark pasts of abuse to effectively hide and keep operating under the radar as they might have in the past.
Saddleback Church backs Rick Warren successor despite allegations
Questions have been raised about the leadership style of Andy Wood, pastor of Echo Church in San Francisco, days after he was announced as Warren's successor.
https://religionnews.com/2022/06/12/saddleback-backs-rick-warren-successor-despite-allegations-andy-wood-echo-church/?fbclid=IwAR0cI2RB7w-UllQhs8sF_2K3Bz42TeTL8yzV952D1N5oCEnVn8mv892tuzA